Loading...
Project 151 - Proposal - Hamers - 1999-11-03 ® ROBIN B. HAMERS 234E 17TH ST SUITE 205 & ASSOCIATES, INC COSTA MESA, CA 92627 CIVIL ENGINEERS • PLANNERS • SURVEYORS (949)548-1182 FAX(949)548-9516 November 3 1999 Board of Directors Costa Mesa Sanitary District P 0 Box 1200 Costa Mesa, CA 92628 RE. PROPOSAL TO PROVIDE INSPECTION SERVICES PROJECT 1112100-151 FAIRVIEW ROAD SEWER Dear Board of Directors: The following proposal is for providing the necessary construction administration, engineering, construction surveying and inspection services during the construction phase of the project. Attached are copies of the project reports as described in the Capital Improvement Program as well as the Boyle Engineering independent report. It is proposed to provide the following services, as needed, during the construction phase of the project, not to exceed$10,400 Engineering $ 63 00/hr Inspection 42.00/hr Surveying(2 man crew) 155 00/hr Surveying (3 man crew) 185 00/hr Sincerely eitpil., Robin B Hamers 3 Printed on Recycled Pape PROJECT 1112100-151 RECONSTRUCTING VARIOUS SEWER LINES The project is similar to past projects #122 126 132 140 and 145 which includes rehabilitation and maintenance of the existing gravity sewer line system on an as-needed basis The results of the original four large televising projects plus the small yearly projects have disclosed existing problems in the main lines such as sags cracked pipe collapsed pipe offset joints and root intrusion The project sets up a priority list of the problem areas and repairs the lines on this basis The project is a yearly project and part of an ongoing maintenance program The only problem type mentioned above which is not repaired by this project is root intrusion which is handled through root cutting by the District Throughout the past projects of this type the District has repaired the problem areas using two different methods Two of the projects were designed using standard remove and replace construction where the contractor excavates down to the line, makes the repair and then backfills and repaves One of the projects was completed using Link-Pipe where stainless steel sleeves were inserted into the line adjusted to the right location using a camera, and then expanded to permanently seal itself Link-Pipe is generally an easier and more economical repair method however it has some limitations in its application The decision to use Link-Pipe or remove and replace construction will be made during the design phase when the scope of each repair is more fully investigated Previous costs for excavation and reconstruction have been approximately $650/foot since the footage is only between two and six feet This would allow approximately 35 locations to be included in the project Link-Pipe costs have averaged $3 500 per location or approximately $700 per foot - 7 - An estimate of the project costs is as follows Design $ 9 600 Construction 115 000 Inspection 10 400 Reserve or Contingency 15 000 TOTAL $ 150, 000 - 8 - Soule Engineering Corporation CC_ I.J: s _ r 1 Co it F'O .0_ FAX 7 / 7' N't port CA _ '020 _ •E1 Lit:1'.rri :•iI1^4`ir^>_ -.- t-r- ._a:.iEPnr;ir_ . a'. .`,:raiSarc ='Y°^'Fnrr"=cc:" TRRfISPORTRTJOrl SERVICES Mr Robin Robin B Hamers. PE, Manager/District Engineer August 12. 1996 COSTA MESA SANITARI DISTRICT Post Office Box 1200 Costa Mesa, California 92628-1200 Capital Improvement Program Review I have completed m\ review of the District s 1996-97 Capital Improvement Program (CIP) that You sent me on June 10 1996 I have enclosed m\ independent review report as you requested. As usual. I found the CIP report to be ven complete. containing adequate information for me to make m\ review The use of vicinity maps. lists and recap sheets was beneficial, it made m\ - reviev easier Overall I found the CIP report to be \es concise. v ell du ned. and complete. I applaud you. the District a,ad the cits fc undertaking the Se\.cr ia:a:a: Stu,: "f ,e e,:d esui, should he \:ci1 recei\ed b\ the end users, the -esideuts and businesses of Costa Mesa. I appreciate the opportunit\ to continue to work \vitit you and serve the District. Best shes to \ou. the Directors. and the District staff. Boyle Engineering Corporation Bruce D Mattem. PE Assistant Managing Engineer Enclosure CIP Revie\\ Report OC-C I IOC-0t/crosdlet oc2 'BD\tn Indep.ndent Review Costa Mesa Sanitary District Capital Impro‘cment Program Fiscal Y car 1996-97 e Project 1112100-149/SINKING FUND This is the second year that funds have been set aside for future replacement or econsi-uction of sewer Imes as they reach life expectancy Setting aside funds for future use now «ill benefit from compounding over time. o Project 1112100-150/PUMP STATION ALARM SYSTEM UPDATE The Districts existing radio-alarm system is reaching its life expectancy Parts ma} be obta.nable for the radios but the alarm reporting system appears to be unsahageable. The District Engineer has recommended that bids include replacing the radios as an alternative, which I support. The use of a radio-alarm system has great value and benefit. The main saving has been in reduced response time. auto snut down of pumps when a problem has occurred. and a reduction in overflows when there has --- been a failure. The construction cost appears reasonable a3 does the design and inspection fees. s Project 1112100-151/SEWER LINE RECONSTRLCTION \ arious Locations This is the sixth allocaticn in a continuing prokraim to provide funding for n aimenance of °wer lines at arious locations. This is a maintenance program and priorities are established -om the data and anal\ sis recei ed from previous televising of the Districts sewer lines. Since repairs are small in length the a\-erage cost per toot will be higher when compared to major replacement projects. The engineers estimate appears reasonable. The design and inspection fees of 8.3% and 9% respecti\clv appeai to be within acceptable standards. The 13% contingenc' estimate is reasonable. o Project 1112100-152/TELEVISING SEWER LINES This is part of an ongoing program to insure that the Districts facilities are functioning properly The District Engineer proposes to check lines that were televised approximately eight years ago this will provide significant information in which to dray assumptions rega:dmg other portions of the Districts faciliti,. The engineering fees are higher than normal projects but since this requires proper selection of locations to be telex ised coupled \ ith reviewing the tapes and report preparation, the seem acceptable. The inclusion of the vicinity map was beneficial and appreciated. e Project 11121100-153/ROOT INTRUSION STUDY Sewer Laterals This is the first year for this program. It appears to be a joint effort between the District nd the Cit to pro, ide a public ser ice as well as helping to identify potential problems/conflicts. The District and the City should be complimented for undertaking this project. especial!', the District for funding this first phase. Hopefully the public will \iev this as a posits\e step and that the information can he used for pre entati\e maintenance rather than fume- pointing. I whole heartilx support this program. Again. the use of the vicinit\ map was beneficial. PROJECT 1112100-151 RECONSTRUCTING VARIOUS SEWER LINES The project is similar to past projects #122 , 126, 132, 140 and 145 which includes rehabilitation and maintenance of the existing gravity sewer line system on an as-needed basis The results of the original four large televising projects plus the small yearly projects have disclosed existing problems in the main lines such as sags, cracked pipe collapsed pipe offset joints, and root intrusion The project sets up a priority list of the problem areas and repairs the lines on this basis The project is a yearly project and part of an ongoing maintenance program The only problem type mentioned above which is not repaired by this project is root intrusion which is handled through root cutting by the District Throughout the past projects of this type the District has repaired the problem areas using two different methods Two of the projects were designed using standard remove and replace construction where the contractor excavates down to the line, makes the repair, and then backfills and repaves One of the projects was completed using Link-Pipe, where stainless steel sleeves were inserted into the line adjusted to the right location using a camera, and then expanded to permanently seal itself Link-Pipe is generally an easier and more economical repair method however it has some limitations in its application The decision to use Link-Pipe or remove and replace construction will be made during the design phase when the scope of each repair is more fully investigated Previous costs for excavation and reconstruction have been approximately $650/foot since the footage is only between two and six feet This would allow approximately 35 locations to be included in the project Link-Pipe costs have averaged $3 500 per location or approximately $700 per foot - 7 - An estimate of the project costs is as follows Design $ 9, 600 Construction 115, 000 Inspection 10,400 Reserve or Contingency 15, 000 TOTAL $ 150 000 - 8 - Soule Engineering Corporation ccr 5u un0 enclr.cers / a. i,5cs 7 u1 Ouch; -troc- 714 00 PO. Box 'Oo,O FAX 71 /i2 7' No 'port co" CA..e65S-5020 Telex 6-.5561 .r,(194sV1Y_JhnSSia r:s .^MI,T,'�`�.isT or.ro `�`'r�{Goi- Pe-Walto -`flZnlL� i5td�T�Te==-0 TRRrISPORTRTIOrl SERVICES Mr Robin B Hamers, PE, Manager/District Engineer August 12. 1996 COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT Post Office Box 1200 Costa Mesa, California 92628-1200 Capital Improvement Program Review -I have completed my review, of the District s 1996-97 Capital Improvement Program (CIP) that you sent me on June 10 1996. I have enclosed m} independent review report as you requested. As usual, I found the CIP report to be very complete. containing adequate information for me to make my review The use of vicinity maps. lists and recap sheets was beneficial, it made m), revien easier Overall I found the CIP report to be very concise. well defined. and complete. I applaud you. the District and the cit, for undertaking the Sewer Lateral Stuc The end essults should be well reveled by the end users, the residents and businesses of Costa Mesa. I appreciate the opportunity to continue to work with you and serve the District. Best wishes to you. the Directors. and the District staff. Boyle Engineering Corporation _ acv, Bruce D Mattem. PE Assistant Managing Engineer Enclosure CIP Reviev Report OC-C 1-100-tb/crosdlet oc2713D?1.n Independent Review Costa Mesa Sanitary District Capital Improvement Program Fiscal Year 1996-97 s Project 1112100-149/SINKING FUND This is the second year that funds have been set aside for future replacement or reconstruction of sewer lines as they reach life expectancy Setting aside funds for future use now will benefit from compounding over time. o Project 1112100-150/PUMP STATION ALARM SYSTEM UPDATE The Districts existing radio-alarm system is reaching its life expectancy Parts may be obtainable for the radios but the alarm reporting system appears to be unsalvageable. The District Engineer has recommended that bids include replacing the radios as an alternative, which I support. The use of a radio-alarm system has great value and benefit. The main saving has been in reduced response time. auto shut down of pumps when a problem has occurred. and a reduction in overflows when there has been a failure. The construction cost appears reasonable as does the design and inspection fees. e Project 1112100-151/SEWER LINE RECONSTRUCTION Various Locations This is the sixth allocation in a continuing program to provide funding for maintenance of sewer lines at various locations. This is a maintenance program and priorities are established from the data and analysis received from previous televising of the Districts sewer lines. Since repairs are small in length the a■-erage cost per foot will be higher when compared to major replacement projects. The engineers estimate appears reasonable. The design and inspection fees of 8 3% and 9% respect nely appear to be within acceptable standards. The 13% contingent} estimate is reasonable. o Project 1112100-152/TELEVISING SEWER LINES This is part of an ongoing program to insure that the Districts facilities are functioning properly The District Engineer proposes to check lines that were televised approximately eight years ago this will provide significant information in which to draw assumptions regarding other portions of the Districts facilities. The engineering fees are higher than normal projects but since this requires proper selection of locations to be televised coupled with reviewing the tapes and report preparation. they seem acceptable. The inclusion of the vicinity map was beneficial and appreciated. + Project 11121100-153/ROOT INTRUSION STUDY Sewer Laterals This is the first year for this program. It appears to be a joint effort between the District and the City to provide a public service as well as helping to identify potential problems/conflicts. The District and the City should be complimented for undertaking this project. especially the District for funding this first phase. Hopefully the public will view this as a posru'e step and that the information can be used for pretentati\e maintenance rather than finger pointing. I whole hearth support this program. Again. the use of the vicinity, map was beneficial.