Loading...
Minutes - Board - 2011-02-24• COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT MINUTES OF BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING FEBRUARY 24, 2011 CALL TO ORDER The Board of Directors of the Costa Mesa Sanitary District met in regular session on February 24, 2011 at 5:30 p.m. at 628 W. 19th Street, Costa Mesa. PLEDGE OF Director Scheafer led the Pledge of ALLEGIANCE Allegiance. INVOCATION Director Scheafer gave the invocation. • ROLL CALL DIRECTORS PRESENT: Robert Ooten, James Ferryman, Jim Fitzpatrick, Mike Scheafer • DIRECTORS ABSENT: Art Perry was absent and excused. STAFF PRESENT: Scott Carroll, General Manager; Joan Revak, Office Manager /Clerk of the District; Robin B. Hamers, District Engineer; Alan Burns, Legal Counsel; Sherry Kallab, Administrative Manager; Jacque Rogers, Assistant to Treasurer OTHERS PRESENT ANNOUNCEMENT OF LATE COMMUNICATIONS Dean Ruffridge, CR &R George Lazurak, CR &R Dan Worthington Costa Mesa Ms. Revak reported there were no late communications. • U • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 2 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 CONSENT CALENDAR REPORTS MINUTE APPROVAL Minutes of Sewer System Committee Meeting — January 25, 2011 The Minutes of the Sewer System Committee Meeting of January 25, 2011 were approved as distributed. Minutes of Recycling Committee Meeting The Minutes of the Recycling Committee January 24, 2011 Meeting of January 24, 2011 were approved as distributed. Minutes of Regular Board Meeting — January 27, 2011 Minutes of the Special Board Meeting - February 1, 2011 Minutes of the Special Board Meeting — February 9, 2011 Minutes of the Special Board Meeting — January 19, 2011 FINANCIAL REPORTS Refunds Occupancy Report and Payment of $197,060.83 to Costa Mesa Disposal — January 2011 The Minutes of the Regular Board Meeting of January 27, 2011 were approved as distributed. The Minutes of the Special Board Meeting of February 1, 2011 were approved as distributed. The Minutes of the Special Board Meeting of February 9, 2011 were approved as distributed. The Minutes of the Special Board Meeting of January 19, 2011 were approved as distributed. There were no refund requests for the month of January 2011. The Trash Occupancy Count documented an increase of five units for the occupancy report for solid waste collection as of February 1, 2011. Therefore, the total for January is 21,524 and the payment of $197,060.83 was ratified. r1 LJ COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 3 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 Contract Payment of $162,676.81 to CR Transfer — January 2011 Contract Payment of $11,223.12 to CR Transfer — Santa Ana Heights /Newport Beach — January 2011 Warrant Register for the month of January 2011 in the amount of $682,530.55 Directors Compensation & Reimbursement of Expenses for the month of January 2011. Investment Report for the month of January 2011 ENGINEER'S REPORTS Project Status Report The contract payment of $162,676.81 to CR Transfer for recycling services and disposal for the month of January 2011 was ratified as submitted. The contract payment of $11,223.12 to CR Transfer for recycling services and disposal for Santa Ana Heights /Newport Beach for the month of January 2011 was ratified as submitted. Warrant Resolution #CMSD 2011 -8 was approved, authorizing the President and Secretary to sign the warrant ratifying the payment of certain claims and demands, and specifying the funds out of which the same were paid in the amount of $682,530.55. Director Compensation and Expense Reimbursements for the month of January 2011 were approved and ratified as follows: President Ooten: $1,326.00 + $147.68 Vice President Ferryman: $884.00 Director Scheafer: $1,326.00 + $220.89 Director Fitzpatrick: $1,326.00 Director Perry: $1,326.00 + $152.62 The Investment Report for the month of January 2011 was approved as submitted. The Project Status Report dated January 2011 was accepted as submitted. END OF CONSENT CALENDAR • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 4 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 Vice President Ferryman moved to accept the Consent Calendar. Director Fitzpatrick requested items A. 4 and 5 be pulled and Director Scheafer requested item C.9 be pulled. Director Fitzpatrick seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. Director Fitzpatrick questioned paragraph 2.1 on Solid Waste — Explore Commercial Collection Services. President Ooten stated his opinion that the minutes accurately reflect that the item would be taken back to the Recycling Committee for further review and be brought back to the Board at a later time. Director Fitzpatrick moved to adopt the minutes of February 1, 2011. Director Ferryman seconded the motion. Motion passed 4 -0. Director Fitzpatrick stated the Board had a discussion on Styrofoam and Staff was asked to bring back a policy on banning placement of Styrofoam in District containers. Director Scheafer moved to adopt the minutes of the meeting held on February 9, 2010. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. On Item C.9., Director Scheafer questioned the Occupancy Report Count and the meaning of a net increase of 5 units. Ms. Kallab stated it meant there was an increase of 5 new services, not necessarily new buildings. Director Scheafer moved to accept the Trash Occupancy Count as presented. Director Fitzpatrick seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. WRITTEN COMMUNICATIONS Ms. Revak presented an invitation from the Costa Mesa Historical Preservation Committee and the Costa Mesa Historical Society to the Diego Sepulveda Adobe Reopening Ceremony on Saturday, March 5, 2011 at 10:00 a.m. PUBLIC COMMENTS President Ooten requested any public comments. Mr. Dan Worthington, former CMSD Director, requested the Board consider two items be agendized in the future. The first issue Mr. Worthington presented was of creating new voting divisions by dividing the City into five voting districts and stated his opinion on advantages for the Board members and the voters. The second issue Mr. Worthington presented was on term limits and he pointed out the forms of government having term limits. Mr. Worthington stated a better form of government exists when there has to be an automatic change of representation avoiding stagnation and fresh ideas come from freshly elected people who see things differently. President Ooten thanked Mr. Worthington for attending. GENERAL MANAGER'S REPORTS Mr. Carroll informed the Board the U. S. Green Building Council is going to certify the new Yard building as "Platinum" LEED. The District will receive a plaque with this designation. This is the first building in the City of Costa Mesa with a • Platinum LEED designation. COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 5 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 PRELIMINARY BUDGET CALENDAR FOR FISCAL YEAR 2011 -12 Mr. Carroll presented a schedule for the fiscal year 2011 -12 Budget Calendar. Director Fitzpatrick' moved to accept the 2011 -12 Budget Calendar and set the date of Wednesday, April 27, 2011 at 5:30 p.m. to review the preliminary budget; and, if necessary, another budget meeting will be held on Thursday, May 12, 2011 at 5:30 p.m.. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. SALARY RANGE ADJUSTMENT —ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES MANAGER Mr. Carroll requested a salary range adjustment for the Administrative Services Manager with the justification that the position serves as a department head overseeing personnel and financing functions. More recently, the position has taken on risk management roles such as being the administrator of the District's Injury Illness and Prevention Program. Mr. Carroll presented data on the salary ranges for similar positions in other organizations. Director Fitzpatrick stated he is supportive of the increase, however, in the future requested comparisons with Districts other than "Water' be used. Director Fitzpatrick moved to approve the salary range adjustment for the Administrative Services Manager with an annual low salary of $69,892 and a maximum $90,479 retroactive from October 2010 through February 2011. Director Schaefer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. ANTI - SCAVENGING PROGRAM Mr. Carroll reported Staff has developed a program in an attempt to deter scavenging from occurring within District boundaries, as scavenging recyclable materials from the residential automated carts can have a negative impact on the community in two different and distinct ways: Recyclable material is a commodity and the revenues received from recyclables help stabilize costs for providing collection services. Fewer recyclables collected and processed means fewer revenues to offset expenditures, which can result in cost increases that are passed on to residents in the rate structure. Cities in California are required to divert 50% of waste from the landfills. In 2007, the State changed its reporting requirement to comply with AB 939 by establishing a per capita disposal rate and the State establishes a specific annual per capita disposal rate of 8.5 pounds per resident. The City depends on District data to help achieve this target. In 2009 the City's annual per capita disposal rate is 5.1 pounds per resident which is well below the State's target. Fewer recyclables received could result in an increase of irefuse tonnage being reported to the City thus increasing its per capita disposal rate per resident and jeopardizing the State mandated target. In addition, the District has a Strategic Plan goal to divert annually 60% • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 6 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 of residential waste from the landfills. Currently, the District is achieving a 54% annual diversion rate. Fewer recyclables received could increase refuse tonnage delivered to the landfills, which could result in decreasing the District's diversion rate. Mr. Carroll reported Staff met with the City of Costa Mesa and CR &R Staff to discuss the level of scavenging that is occurring in the community and to work together on developing a program to deter such activity. At the meeting it was determined scavenging of recyclable materials is a problem in the community where the Police Department is receiving an average of 120 scavenging reports a year in the last two years. Staff has also explored using lockable containers. On collection day, residents lock their containers with a key and when CR &R's refuse trucks arrive to empty the containers, the lid will open from the weight of materials being emptied into the truck. It is not necessary for the driver to exit his vehicle to unlock the container before emptying it. CR &R has offered their assistance to the program by offering these types of containers to District residents. CR &R has agreed to purchase the lockable containers, deliver the new containers to homeowners, switch out the old containers and maintain the lockable containers. The lockable containers would be available on request only. Residents wanting to receive lockable containers will be required to call the District office for such a request and Staff will coordinate with CR &R on a delivery date to homeowners. To advertise the new containers, Staff will post information on the District's website and will provide information in the next newsletters. Director Scheafer stated the residents have a responsibility to protect their own identities and should not depend on the District. Director Scheafer suggested the District publicize this through newsletters and the website. There would be a charge for more than two containers. Director Fitzpatrick asked what obligation the District has. District Counsel stated the CMSD does have the responsibility to the hauler to protect the recycle stream for the contractor but does not have the obligation to enforce the law. Mr. Ruffridge stated a CR &R concern if this is very successful with the community, would the additional residents be placed on a waiting list or would the Board consider the use of other funds to use for additional lockable containers. Mr. Carroll stated it would be a decision for the Board to make should that situation occur. COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 7 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 Director Fitzpatrick suggested the District encourage residents to place their recyclables in the lockable containers to prevent the loss of recyclables from the waste stream. Director Fitzpatrick motioned to direct Staff to adopt the Staff's recommendation of the anti - scavenging program along with recommendations from the Recycling Committee to include the provision that one container be allocated per household. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. REVISED STANDBY POLICY Mr. Carroll presented a Revised Standby Policy for consideration by the Board of Directors to approve a revision to Administrative Regulation No. 2.14 regarding standby procedures and protocols. Currently, C &R Drains is the District's first responder when an emergency arises during non - regular business hours for incidents such as a failed pump station or an SSO. C &R Drains has been in the sewer business for thirty years and they are located locally in Costa Mesa. Per • the terms of the agreement, C &R Drains must respond immediately to after hour service calls and they must be on -site within thirty minutes or less after receiving the call. Because they have staff living in or near Costa Mesa, C &R Drains is able to meet this requirement of the contract. After arriving to the emergency scene, CR &R will sometimes rely on staff's expertise and knowledge on the system so C &R will call staff on their day off seeking advice and /or to receive directions. The previous maintenance supervisor did not charge the District for after hour telephone conversations with C &R Drains; however, the District did pay him overtime for responding to emergencies during non - regular work hours. The previous supervisor. was the only non - exempt employee who would receive after hour phone calls from C &R Drains and was usually the only person responding to incidents if the situation required. The District's Lead Maintenance Worker is now responsible for receiving after hour phone calls from C &R and responding to emergencies Monday through Thursday, but during the weekends and holidays, the District will have three non - exempt employees available to assist C &R Drains (Lead Maintenance Worker and 2 Maintenance Workers). • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 8 MINUTES OF THE BOARD. OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 0 Mr. Carroll stated the three District employees will be available to C &R Drains on rotating weekend shifts and holidays. According to Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), if employees are restricted and are effectively "engaged to wait" then compensation is required. However, the amount of compensation is determined by the employer. Mr. Carroll stated the following standby compensation is proposed for the Board's consideration. A flat fee of $50.00 per day while on standby status. If C &R Drains calls the standby person, he will be paid his standard hourly rate with a guarantee of at least one hour of pay. The standard hourly rate varies from $24.16 to $28.75 an hour. If the emergency cannot be resolved over the phone and the standby person needs to respond to the scene, he will be paid the overtime rate of one and one -half times his hourly rate. Mr. Carroll stated District Counsel has reviewed and approved the revised Standby Policy, which is attached hereto. • The flat fee for standby compensation will cost the District $9,550 a year. The costs'for handling incidents by phone and the cost for overtime is difficult to estimate because these costs will fluctuate year by year depending on how many emergencies arises. Director Ferryman moved to approve the Revised Standby Policy. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. SPECIAL BOARD MEETING ON "BRANDING" Mr. Carroll stated this item was discussed at the Strategic Planning session. Director Ferryman suggested bringing in a consultant to assist with this process. Director Scheafer agreed and suggested CMSD Board and Staff hold a meeting to discuss the issue and then decide if a consultant is necessary. Director Fitzpatrick stated he would like to see Maintenance Staff dressed in really nice District uniforms, and vehicles with the District Seal better maintained exterior wise. Director Fitzpatrick expressed the desire for better publicity of the District. A meeting is scheduled for Thursday, March 17, 2011 at 11:00 a.m. Mr. Hamers stated he is unable to attend and also noted that this was addressed by the Board many years ago and the District thought about changing the name to better separate itself from the City. • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 9 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 BUDGET ADJUSTMENT - SEISMIC STUDY ON PUMP STATIONS Mr. Carroll reported funds in the amount of $29,400 are required for a study to evaluate the District Pump Station's ability to withstand a major earthquake. Mr. Carroll noted a recommendation was made by the sewer committee to follow Orange County Sanitation District's lead and conduct an evaluation of the effect of a large earthquake on the District's pump stations. Requests for proposals were sent to four structural engineers. One of four engineers, Jerry Tucker, responded with a proposal in the amount of $29,400. A transfer from the contingency account to professional services will be required to fund the study. Director Ferryman moved to approve the budget adjustment in the amount of $29,400 to fund a study to evaluate the District Pump Station's ability to withstand a major earthquake. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. RECYCLING COMMITTEE Director Fitzpatrick reported on the Recycling Committee meeting held on February 22, 2011, and brought attention to the structure of the agenda and giving more perspective on new discussion items. The Committee developed a list of participants who will be invited to the meetings including Mike Carey, OCC, Trisha Throop, CR &R, the City of Costa Mesa Recycling Coordinator and a representative from Earth Resources Foundation. Director Fitzpatrick reported Staff will develop a "Recycling Calendar" to be efficient with time and resources. Director Fitzpatrick discussed the Recycling Reports and stated his opinion that the numbers were not that meaningful. Director Fitzpatrick requested Staff to provide some comparative numbers. Director Ferryman asked if Director Fitzpatrick was asking Staff to investigate other Cities waste stream numbers and stated CR &R should have this information. Mr. Ruffridge stated CR &R can provide this information. Director Ferryman stated his opinion that Staff can obtain this information from CR &R and it is not a realistic or good use of Staff's time performing a study. Mr. Ruffridge reported on a study CR &R did for the CMSD a few years ago and CR &R hired a consulting firm to analyze what was left in the barrels and the majority was organics. CR &R has all the numbers and can supply to the CMSD. C COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 PAGE 10 Director Fitzpatrick stated he would like to have "Zero Waste" on the next agenda and the Recycling Committee would develop a plan on how to define "Zero Waste ". Mr. Ruffridge presented a report on the CMSD Waste Characterization Study performed on the mixed solid waste collected from January 25 through February 2, 2011 for the Costa Mesa and Santa Ana Heights Districts. Mr. Ruffridge reported CR &R performs random sampling of routes from various partner municipalities to establish waste characterizations for incoming loads to the CR Transfer processing plant. The random sampling and corresponding diversion levels of the samples from each load establish a new diversion percentage for each municipality. The procedure is approved by the Cal Recycle Board and is accomplished under the direction of a consultant specializing in waste characterizations. Mr. Ruffridge reported a significant increase in diversion going forward for both communities of the Costa Mesa Sanitary District with 54.14% for Costa Mesa and 51.97% for Santa Ana Heights. Director Ferryman stated the Board needs to make a conscious decision on how aggressive the District wants to be in recycling percentages and the cost involved. Anything over 50% required by the state costs $55.52/ton and the ratepayers need to know that fact. There is an economic consequence to increase the recycling percentage.. Ms. Revak reported on the school telephone book program and practices by many of the schools participating in the 2010 program. The schools participating who achieved good results shared their tactics that included collection of phone books yearlong; reaching out via e-mail distributions lists, to parents, grandparents, friends, work places, local businesses even to those living outside the area; large signs placed on the collection dumpster as a reminder to parents and to attract attention from people passing the schools who wish to participate in recycling; students and teachers make telephone calls to friends; flyers; e-mail; school website and word of mouth. Director Fitzpatrick reported the District was informed by OC Waste & Recycling of a project extension of three years to December 31, 2013 for the Grant program. Director Fitzpatrick expressed his desire for more Director participation in the Recycling Committee. • Director Fitzpatrick stated the next meeting date for the Recycling Committee is March 22, 2011. COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT . PAGE 11 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 ENGINEER'S REPORTS Mr. Hamers stated he had nothing to report. SEWER SYSTEM COMMITTEE Director Ooten reported on the Sewer System Committee meeting held February 15, 2011 with all five Directors participating. TREASURER'S REPORTS Ms. Rogers stated she had nothing to report. ATTORNEY'S REPORTS MANAGER -BOARD COMMUNICATIONS AND ISSUES Mr. Burns stated he was advised by the General Manager that the Board of Directors would like legal guidance on the subject of General Manager communications to the Board with regard to the Brown Act and other District rules. Mr. Burns stated this was a hot topic recently and produced an appellate decision, Wolfe v. City of Fremont, which had generally held that a city manager could lobby his council members with what he wanted to accomplish as long as he did not advise any council member of another council member's position. Mr. Burns advised that it produced a quick legislative abrogation of the Wolfe case, and Government Code Section 54952.2 was enacted. That section clarified that no person should use a series of communications (including faxes or emails) to discuss subject matter within the agency's jurisdiction. It provided, however, that it would not be a violation for an employee such as the General Manager or any official (Board. member, etc.) from engaging in separate conversations or communications to answer questions or provide information (newsletters or similar emails) if that person does not communicate the comments or positions of other members'of the legislative body. This would allow the General Manager to send a communication to all Board members as long as the communication did not mention the comments or positions of other Board members and, it would not be appropriate for a Board member to respond with "reply all" because a Board member would have communicated his position with the others. Mr. Burns provided a copy of • his June 26, 2009 memo to the Board on this subject. COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 12 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 • Mr. Burns also informed the Board of another issue the Board of Directors desired guidance on was whether it is appropriate to provide other Board members with information provided in response to one Board member's inquiry. Mr. Burns reported the District actually has a rule directly on -point that was adopted when a previous Board member was requiring an inordinate amount of Staff time. Mr. Burns stated the Manager shall respond to individual Board member inquiries unless the Manager determines it would take an inordinate amount of time, in which case full Board approval is to be sought. Further, it provided that copies of materials prepared for one Director shall be distributed to all Directors. This rule is set forth in District Operations Code Section 3.01.100. Director Fitzpatrick stated his opinion that the Manager exercise his discretion in responding to requests by one Director as to whether it is necessary to divulge the matter to the entire Board. Mr. Burns stated there is a special rule with regard to emails and Directors should not send emails between each other. CLERK OF THE DISTRICT REPORTS • PROCLAMATION FOR ALLAN ROEDER, COSTA MESA CITY MANAGER Ms. Revak provided a Proclamation for Costa Mesa City Manager for presentation at the celebration of Mr. Roeder's career on March 3, 2011. Director Fitzpatrick requested the District seal be placed on the proclamation and Ms. Revak assured the Board a gold seal with the District's seal would be placed below the signatures and the proclamation would be nicely framed. Director Ferryman moved to direct the President and Secretary of the CMSD Board of Directors to sign the proclamation. Director Scheafer seconded the motion. Motion carried 4 -0. LOCAL MEETINGS ORANGE COUNTY SANITATION DISTRICT (OCSD) Director Ferryman gave a report on the OCSD meeting held on February 23, 2011. Other Meetings Qualifying for Reimbursement Director Fitzpatrick reported he is attending classes at California . Residential Recycling Association (CRRA) where he is learning about general recycling, zero waste, C &D and organics and'will be credentialed in waste management upon completion of the program. • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 13 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 President Ooten and Director Perry attended the CMSD Sewer System Sub - Committee meeting where they study hot spots. Director Fitzpatrick reported on the City /Districts Liaison Committee and stated his opinion thatt it was one of the most effective meetings he has attended. OLD BUSINESS There was no old business to discuss. NEW BUSINESS SDRMA Notification of Nominations — 2011 Election Board of Directors Director Scheafer expressed his desire to be nominated for the SDRMA seat that is up for reelection should he not be selected for the CSDA seat. The SDRMA term of office is for 4 years beginning January 1, 2012 and expiring December 31, 2015. Nomination documents must be received in i SDRMA's office no later than 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 4, 2011. This item will be continued to the March 24,'2011 meeting. ORAL COMMUNICATIONS AND DIRECTOR COMMENTS Discussion was held on the comments made earlier in the meeting by Mr. Worthington and agreed it would not be in the best interests of the taxpayer to expend funds to investigate measures that would have to take place to determine if the District could break up into sections. ADJOURNMENT President Ooten adjourned the meeting to Closed Session at 7:30.p.m. to discuss personnel performance evaluation pursuant to Government Code Section 54957 for the General Manager President Ooten reconvened the regular meeting at 8:00 p.m. and announced the Board approved a 4% raise for the General Manager and an adjustment in his severance pay from six to nine months. • COSTA MESA SANITARY DISTRICT PAGE 14 MINUTES OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS REGULAR MEETING HELD FEBRUARY 24, 2011 • President Ooten adjourned the meeting at 8:05 p.m. - eretary President • Ll